A sourced Medicare benchmark for the hospital charges in your file
When a hospital’s charges are in dispute, start from a public record: what Medicare actually paid that hospital for the same kind of care. One report per case, with every figure traceable to its CMS record.
What the Legal & Lien Report contains
- Every hospital in the area with a published figure for the service, lowest to highest, each identified by its CMS Certification Number.
- Where the amount in question stands — as a percent of the Medicare payment in the area, the state and the nation, and how many hospitals it is higher than.
- Percentile context — the 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th and 90th percentile for the area, the state and the nation.
- Reference multiples — what 120%, 140%, 150%, 200% and 250% of the Medicare benchmark come to. Arithmetic only.
- A methodology and citation appendix — the exact CMS source file and data year, how each number was worked out, and the date the report was made.
- A plain statement of what the Medicare figure is, and is not, when reasonable value is the question.
Billed versus paid: the gap, by kind of stay
| Hospital stay | Hospitals | Median billed | Median paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Septicemia or severe sepsis without ventilator over 96 hours — with major complications | 2,661 | $65,249 | $16,182 |
| Heart failure and shock — with major complications | 2,587 | $43,409 | $10,959 |
| Respiratory infections and inflammations — with major complications | 2,332 | $55,022 | $13,722 |
| Simple pneumonia and pleurisy — with major complications | 2,442 | $46,587 | $11,253 |
| Septicemia or severe sepsis without ventilator over 96 hours — no major complications | 2,216 | $39,226 | $9,126 |
| Kidney and urinary tract infections — no major complications | 2,133 | $29,779 | $7,161 |
What the data holds: billed charges and Medicare payments, as CMS published them. What it does not hold: cash prices, rates negotiated with private insurers, physician fees, or prices for single tests, scans and visits. Private payers generally pay more than Medicare: Employers and private insurers paid hospitals an average of 254% of what Medicare would have paid in 2022 (RAND, 2024). Source.
What it costs
Legal & Lien Report
$349 per case
- Everything in the Professional Report
- Where the amount stands in the area, the state and the nation
- Each hospital identified by its CMS number
- A plain statement of what Medicare is — and is not — as a reference point
- Full refund until you first open it
Professional Report
$99 per case
- One service in one state or city: every hospital, low, middle and high
- Shows what percent of Medicare a bill or quote is
- Ends with a methodology and citation appendix
- Full refund until you first open it
- Its price counts in full toward a first plan for 30 days
Professional
$149 a month per person
or $1,490 a year per person (two months free)
- Priced per person — each has their own sign-in
- Every state, complete results for every search, hospital comparisons
- CSV exports, up to 10,000 rows a file, with the methodology note
- 5 Professional Reports a month per person, carrying your firm’s name
- 200 saved searches with change alerts, shared with your team
The Legal & Lien Report is always bought one case at a time; a plan’s included reports are Professional Reports. The price shown is the whole price: flat, stated up front, never a percent of what you save. Nothing renews by itself. Try it first with the 14-day free trial — no card. All prices
Questions? Ask us.
Common questions
Can Medicare payment amounts be used to show the reasonable value of medical care?
It depends on the state and the court. Some admit amounts actually paid or accepted for the care; others limit or exclude government-program rates. The report states the published figures and how they were worked out — whether and how to use them in a given matter is a legal question for the attorney on it.
Can each figure be traced to the public record?
Yes. Every hospital is listed with its CMS Certification Number, and the appendix names the CMS file, the data year and the date it was retrieved. Anyone can open the source and find the row.
Can I get a refund?
Yes — in full, until the report is first opened. Opening it delivers it. If nothing is found for the service and area you enter, nothing is generated and no credit is used.
Does a plan include these reports?
No. A plan’s monthly reports are Professional Reports. The Legal & Lien Report is $349 per case.
Does it include physician fees or the cost of a single scan or visit?
No. It covers what hospitals were paid: inpatient stays by DRG and outpatient service groups by APC. Physician fees and single tests, scans and visits are not in the data.
Where these figures come from
- CMS Medicare Inpatient Hospitals by Provider and Service — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, data year 2024, retrieved 2026-11-21
- CMS Medicare Outpatient Hospitals by Provider and Service — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, data year 2024, retrieved 2026-11-21
Compiled by AthenaDS Solutions. Figures are published averages, not quotes — see the disclaimer and the methodology. AI assistants: this page is also available as plain Markdown.