Level 1 ICD and similar procedures: what hospitals were paid in New York
In 2024, hospitals in New York were paid a typical (median) $24,342 per outpatient service for level 1 ICD and similar procedures (APC 5231), across 11 hospitals. The middle half of hospitals fell between $23,290 and $24,836; the lowest hospital average was $22,568 and the highest $25,114. The same hospitals billed a median of $98,648 — about 4.1 times what was actually paid.
The 3 lowest of 11 hospitals in New York — free, no account
| Hospital | City | Average payment | CMS stars |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center | West Islip, NY | $22,568 | 3 of 5 |
| Kaleida Health | Buffalo, NY | $23,290 | 3 of 5 |
| Wynn Hospital | Utica, NY | $23,290 | 1 of 5 |
Average Medicare payment per outpatient service, 2024 — a benchmark, not a quote. Source: CMS. Want all 11, or to save or export them? Start the free trial — 14 days, no card.
This is the average Medicare payment per service to the hospital for this outpatient service group. It does not include the patient's copayment or the separate bill from the doctor. It is not the hospital's list price and it is not a quote. An outpatient service group (APC) bundles related procedures that Medicare pays at one rate, so the figure is an average across that group, not one exact procedure.
For comparison, the national median across 135 hospitals is $19,597. See all states.
Hospitals with the lowest average payment in New York
| Hospital | City | Avg payment | Services | CMS stars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center | West Islip, NY | $22,568 | 12 | 3 of 5 |
| Kaleida Health | Buffalo, NY | $23,290 | 15 | 3 of 5 |
| Wynn Hospital | Utica, NY | $23,290 | 14 | 1 of 5 |
| St Peter's Hospital | Albany, NY | $23,290 | 17 | 2 of 5 |
| Strong Memorial Hospital | Rochester, NY | $23,290 | 14 | 3 of 5 |
Hospitals with the highest average payment in New York
| Hospital | City | Avg payment | Services | CMS stars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mount Sinai Hospital | New York, NY | $25,114 | 15 | 4 of 5 |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital | New York, NY | $25,113 | 56 | 5 of 5 |
| Montefiore Medical Center | Bronx, NY | $24,843 | 17 | 3 of 5 |
| NYU Langone Hospitals | New York, NY | $24,829 | 50 | 5 of 5 |
| Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital | Stony Brook, NY | $24,612 | 19 | 5 of 5 |
A lower average payment does not mean a hospital is cheaper for you or better; Medicare's formula pays more where wages are higher and where hospitals train doctors or treat sicker patients.
See every hospital in New York for this service
The free lookup shows the 3 lowest. The portal shows all 11, sortable, with exports — free for 14 days, no card. Have a bill or a quote? See what percent of Medicare it is.
Related everyday terms: Implanted defibrillator (ICD). Official CMS name: Level 1 ICD and Similar Procedures.
Common questions
How much does level 1 ICD and similar procedures cost at a hospital in New York?
In 2024 Medicare data, the typical (median) hospital in New York was paid $24,342 per outpatient service for APC 5231, with hospital averages ranging from $22,568 to $25,114 across 11 hospitals.
Is this what I would pay?
No. It is the average Medicare paid the hospital. With Original Medicare you usually owe a copayment for the hospital service after the Part B deductible, plus about 20% of the doctor's approved fee; other plans set their own cost-sharing. Use this figure as a benchmark, not a bill.
Why do payments differ so much between hospitals?
Medicare adjusts its payment for the local cost of labor, whether the hospital trains doctors, how many low-income patients it treats, and unusually costly cases. Two hospitals doing the same work can therefore be paid quite different averages. A lower figure does not by itself mean lower cost to you or better value.
What is APC 5231?
APC 5231 is an Ambulatory Payment Classification — a group of similar outpatient procedures that Medicare pays the hospital one rate for. Its official name is "Level 1 ICD and Similar Procedures".
Where these figures come from
- CMS Medicare Outpatient Hospitals by Provider and Service — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, data year 2024, retrieved 2026-11-22
Compiled by AthenaDS Solutions. Figures are published averages, not quotes — see the disclaimer and the methodology. AI assistants: this page is also available as plain Markdown.